Another delightful book in the series. I realized when reading it that I had in fact read it before. It features many more relatable kid moments, fascinating historical details, and a total lack of Suck Fairy.

Gertie lies that she can tell time, and then gets stuck running to check the time for her teacher at the school clock, where she lurks miserably until some passerby rescues her. Most writers would use this to hammer home a "don't lie" message. In fact, Gertie spends so much time desperately staring at the clock that she eventually learns to tell time ahead of her class!

Slovenly but kind Uncle Hyman has a romance with Lena, a brave and plump recent immigrant. Everything about this romance between very unglamorous, middle-aged people is completely lovely. Also...


Lena contracts polio and her left leg is paralyzed. She's really unhappy about this and breaks off the engagement, figuring she's now not fit to be a wife. Hyman very much disagrees, and so does Mom, who convinces her that it's not so. And she goes to her wedding and slowly walks down the aisle, and there's an illustration of her dancing in her brace!

This was especially satisfying to read after What Katie Did and multiple other children's books that do say that a disabled woman cannot marry and must break off the engagement for her husband's sake.



More All-of-a-Kind Family

sovay: (Viktor & Mordecai)

From: [personal profile] sovay


Slovenly but kind Uncle Hyman has a romance with Lena, a brave and plump recent immigrant. Everything about this romance between very unglamorous, middle-aged people is completely lovely.

Yaaaaaaaaaaaaay.

From: [personal profile] riarambles


I feel like you'd love to see this if you haven't already seen it, as it gives some information about the grown-up lives of all the real-life counterparts of the children in the books: https://jewishlibraries.org/images/downloads/Sydney_Taylor_Book_Award/companion.pdf


sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)

From: [personal profile] sholio


Oh wow, I remember the time thing VERY clearly. Definitely relatable to wee!me -- not that specific thing, but that thing where you lie to adults about being able to do something and then end up having to put yourself through all kinds of shenanigans trying to avoid admitting that you don't actually know how to do it.
author_by_night: (Default)

From: [personal profile] author_by_night


What a lovely twist. :) This sounds like a great book. I always loved historical fiction growing up. I still read it now, but for some reason haven't been as satisfied. I think I have the bad luck of picking up the ones that are... fine, but not so much on the depicting history as they are desperate housewives/lonely maidens falling into the arms of Hunky Historics. Or they just don't really capture the history. I'm not saying they're all bad, lots of them are still great, just that this is exactly the sort of thing I loved so much growing up.
adrian_turtle: (Default)

From: [personal profile] adrian_turtle


The first book has that sort of romance! It hinges on tragic misunderstanding and weird coincidence and the girls sigh that it's just like a storybook. (And then they go on to really exciting things, like a day trip to Coney Island.)
naomikritzer: (Default)

From: [personal profile] naomikritzer


Have you ever toured the Tenement Museum in NYC, by the way? If you're ever in NYC, it really lets you step inside the books. (They do living-history tours.)
sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)

From: [personal profile] sholio


Ooooh, that sounds VERY useful from a historical writing perspective. *makes note*
cinaed: Tough times don't last, tough people do, remember? (Gregory Peck)

From: [personal profile] cinaed


Seconding The Tenement Museum!

There's multiple tours and I only managed The Hard Times one for my visit, but it was a great tour and super fascinating to look at the people's lives and the shifting demographics of immigrants in the neighborhood.
landofnowhere: (Default)

From: [personal profile] landofnowhere


Before reading this review I couldn't have told you much about what was in this book, except that I think it was where I learned about Yom Kippur. But now it's coming back to me! I really want to reread this. Also I remembered that I loved the cover as a kid, but I'd forgotten that it had everyone dressed up in costume.
Edited Date: 2019-06-13 12:31 am (UTC)
skygiants: Izumi and Sig Curtis from Fullmetal Alchemist embracing in front of a giant heart (curtises!)

From: [personal profile] skygiants


Lena and Hyman's story was the EPITOME of romance to me at the age of six and honestly remains so.
wendylove: Wendy: I know such lots of stories (Default)

From: [personal profile] wendylove


I read this book at a formative age, so I think of the Lena plotline every time people are idiots about vaccines. Yeah, there's not a lot of death, but the human cost of infectious disease is significant even on a very personal level. And, yes, Hyman/Lena is #relationshipgoals in many ways. :)
mrissa: (Default)

From: [personal profile] mrissa


I remember rattling on to my mother about Lena and Hyman's romance, as small children do, and my mom absently replying, "Oh, like Joy." Who was a family friend of Grandma's age who had had polio, and married and had three children, all of whom were older than my mom, and I knew them all, and it made the positive disability message all the stronger for me as a small child--that things like What Katy Did where you had to pine away were fake, but things like Lena were real.
branna: (Default)

From: [personal profile] branna


I loved these books when I was a kid.
.

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags